I've heard of 'Dear Author', of course: I'm not THAT much of a neophyte. But I don't really read their reviews. I don't really do MUCH book related stuff that isn't writing, anymore...I need to take a writing vacation just to get caught up on my reading!
But, anyway, when Google Alerts told me that 'Dear Author' had posted a review of
Trifecta, I was excited. And I toddled over to their site (how does one 'toddle' on the internet - I'm not sure, but I manage!), and found the
review. It seemed pretty favorable, really. The criticism made sense, and there was lots of nice stuff said. But then I got to the bottom, and the grade was a "B". I was a bit deflated. All that nice stuff, and only a "B"?
So, I decided to ignore them for a while. It wasn't hard, since I'm drowning in work right now. But then I thought I should go back and read over the criticism again, to make sure I was absorbing it (I DO try to learn from reviews, when I can), and I took a look at some of the other books they've reviewed. And I think they're just working on a different marking scheme than the one I've become used to. There really weren't many highly-graded books on the bar along the top of the page. I checked other books that got "B"s and found
Nowhere Ranch by Heidi Cullinan. The first sentence of the review was "I adored this book" - and it still only got a "B"! So I feel better, now. I got a "B" from Dear Author. Yay! (?)